Eight concealers tested: top picks for dark circles, dry skin and budgets

Concealer can hide the first signs of stress — darker eye bags, sudden spots — but formulas vary widely. Some crease or cake, while others blend smoothly or include skincare actives. A consumer journalist tested a wide range of products to find the best options for different needs and budgets.

The top overall pick was Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer, praised for its long-wearing, buildable coverage and broad shade range, though it is not hydrating and is relatively expensive per millilitre. For budget shoppers the Collection Lasting Perfection concealer was recommended for its matt, buildable finish and low price, with the caveat that it must be blended quickly to avoid patchiness.

Charlotte Tilbury’s Beautiful Skin Radiant concealer was singled out for brightening dark circles while delivering hydrating, skin-friendly ingredients like hyaluronic acid, niacinamide and vitamin C, making it a good multitasking option for the undereye area. Dry-skin types were directed to By Terry’s Hyaluronic Serum Concealer, which contains multiple molecular weights of hyaluronic acid to plump and hydrate, though it is the priciest formula tested and has a smaller shade range.

For a lightweight, serum-like finish the NYX Bare With Me Serum Concealer stood out: it comes in a hygienic pump, blurs texture and feels fresh on the skin, but has a slightly dewy finish that may not suit everyone.

Key Topics

Business, Culture, Beauty, Makeup, Concealer, Skincare, Product-testing