The Rookie's Three-Minute Shock in 'The Choice'

Across its eight seasons The Rookie has had several shocking moments, including the deaths of Captain Zoe Andersen and Jackson West. One of the most startling came in Season 5's 'The Choice,' which concluded the recurring arc of Rosalind Dyer (Annie Wersching) in just three minutes.

Rosalind returns to Los Angeles and forces John Nolan into a horrific death game, trapping his then-girlfriend Bailey Nune in a water-filled tank. She tells Nolan she wants him to kill her rather than see her go back to prison, insisting that "anyone can be turned into a murderer, even a saint." Wersching and Nathan Fillion both drew praise for the episode's intense, emotionally fraught scenes.

John refuses to play Rosalind's game, but before she can be taken into custody she is shot by her acolyte Eli Reynolds, a sudden end that surprised viewers. Lucy Chen's stunned line, "Doesn’t seem real," and Tim Bradford's remark, "She only seemed larger than life," underscore how unexpected the moment felt.

the rookie, the choice, rosalind dyer, annie wersching, john nolan, nathan fillion, bailey nune, eli reynolds, season 5, death scene